Top Ten Shooting Guard Of All Time
So what makes a great shooting guard? Well, they need to be able to shoot, and they need to be able to guard the other team’s guard. Shoot and guard. Ideally, a shooting guard should do those two things extremely well. They also need to move well without the ball, use picks to get open, be able to create their own offence facing the basket, and they should get a few boards and a few assists, a block perhaps and a steal or two (though the last two don’t define the efficiency of a defender).
And for those of you looking for Oscar Robertson on this list, don’t, I’m putting him on the small forward list, along with Dr. J. I’ve seen him listed as everything from point guard to small forward, and since I’ve always heard players talk about him as the first “point-forward”, I’m going to go with small forward.
Honourable mention: Mitch Richmond, Jimmy Walker, Drazen Petrovic (whose career tragically ended early due to his death in a car accident), Hal Greer, Sidney Moncrief, Dave Bing and Dennis Johnson. And a special honourable mention to Dwayne Wade and Michael Redd, Wade who is clearly a great talent and will likely deserve a spot by the end of his career, and Redd is the best all-around shooting guard in the league outside of Bryant and Wade.
10. Reggie Lewis
Reggie Lewis never had a chance to blossom into the dominant player he was destined to become because of his tragic death, but even in his limited time in the league he established himself as one of the best shooting guards of his generation. He was a great passer with more than two assists for every turnover, he had a respectable number of steals each season, and his last couple of seasons he was the best shot-blocking shooting guard in the league, better than even Jordan and Drexler, which says a lot. By his final season he had gotten his free-throw percentage into the high 80’s, and his field-goal percentage was around .500, which rivalled many centers in the league at the time, and blew away most other shooting guards. And on top of that he always pulled in about 5 rebounds a game. He never had the high scoring averages of Drexler or Jordan, but he was getting 20 points a game on a team that feature three Hall-of-Famers in Larry Bird, Robert Parish and Kevin McHale, so the fact that the Celtics felt comfortable making him the number one scoring option while Bird was still there is impressive. Coupled with that, he was a great playoff performer, and in Bird’s final season, the Celtics upset the Cavaliers in the first round thanks in part to Lewis’s 28 point scoring average for the playoffs that year. And when McHale, and Bird left, and Parish was relegated to a minor role, Lewis still managed to lead the Celtics into the playoffs despite the fact that many thought the Celtics were on the verge of the lottery. Had he lived a little longer he would have been a clear-cut top five selection, but though he never reached his prime, he still deserves a spot in the top ten.
9. Ray Allen
Best shooter on the list? Its between him and Reggie, an though Reggie would get my vote for best pure shooter, Allen is better at creating a shot off the dribble, and is almost as good as Miller coming off a screen. Allen is a great long range shooter, and three-point shooter, and has had about a 2-1 assists-to-turn over ration, better than most, and at about the standard for a great shooting guard. He’s also always been a decent rebounder, pulling in about 5 a game for most of his career. With the Bucks and the Supersonics, Allen pulled the weight, and got to the conference finals, but the Supersonics were in rebuilding mode and dumped Allen on Boston in exchange for some draft picks, a great deal for Allen who responded by showing that not only could he run an offence and carry a team, but he could defer to other players and take a smaller role on a true contender to play within a team structure. His reward was his first NBA title. And he’s the best free-throw shooter on the list (over 90% in 9 seasons so far). Once Wade is finished his career, Allen may have to give his spot up in the top ten, but for now, I think Allen is deserving of a spot.
8. George Gervin
The Iceman was always known for his sweet shooting, and with a career field-goal percentage just over .500, and a career scoring average 25+ and several single season averages above or near 30 a game, illustrates that he does fulfill at least one of the duties of the shooting guard, and that is shooting. As good as guards are at shooting, their field-goal percentages seldom meet the averages of most centers and forwards who take higher percentage shots, and also take fewer closing-quarter shots. Those low percentage shots are left for guards. All those low-percentage shots that get thrown up in the closing seconds of a quarter or game do count as miss field goals and drag down shooting percentages. Gervin though deserves much kudos for keeping his average as high as it is, especially considering he that he took as many shots as he did. His ABA years saw him as a strong rebounder, and he was above average in the NBA as well, usually pulling in 5 or 6 a game, but his assist-to-turnover ration could have been a little better. West and Havlicek though are lucky that they can’t be critiqued for their assist-to-turnover averages since the league didn’t keep track of turnovers at the time, but that said, Gervin’s assist averages were somewhat lacking. His defence though was solid as his career averages in steals and blocks are both over one a game, making him one of the best shot blocking guards in the history of the league (a higher career average even than Jordan). He could score and he could defend, but Gervin’s assists number are somewhat lacking. Like Lanier Gervin also never made it to the NBA finals, let alone win an NBA title, so he never got to make any memorable clutch shots. He was great no doubt about it, but there are players who accomplished more and had better all-around games, so he doesn’t get to crack the top five, but he is clearly one of the best scorers the league has ever seen.
7. Reggie Miller
Miller, in my eyes, is easily the best clutch shooter in the history of the league, and I put him above West and Jordon in this aspect without flinching. He was gold from the line, and he was gold in the clutch, and out of all the guards on this list, he is also the best long-distance shooter, and probably the best pure shooter as well. That is not to say he is the best scorer. Reggie Miller could move without the ball better than anybody on this list, and he knew how to come off a screen and get himself open, which is great when you have a good point guard, but Miller wasn’t always great with the ball in his hand. He knew how to get a little space between him and a defender to get a shot off, but when it came to putting the ball on the floor and driving to the basket, he couldn’t create the kind of offence that Bryant, Gervin or Jordan could. Though he wasn’t a cardboard cut out on defence, he wasn’t the strongest defender (though he did work hard), and he didn’t turn the ball over as much as Gervin or Bryant, and took care of the ball almost as well as Dumars. Like Dumars, Miller was more of a pure shooting guard than a versatile shooting guard like Bryant and Jordan, but he did accept his role within the team structure and played it well, helping the Pacer reach the conference finals more than once (losing out to the Bulls in Jordan’s final year) and helping them get to the finals once as well (where the officials handed the title to the Lakers). Though he was limited in his game, the game he played he had mastered and NBC should have been giving him bonuses during the playoffs because I know all of my friends made sure to watch every game that Miller was in, especially against the Knicks and the Bulls (though nobody can forget that performance against Orlando) pushing the ratings up and making the playoffs as entertaining as they could possibly be.
6. Joe Dumars
Why is Dumars ahead of Gervin? His career averages aren’t nearly as impressive as Gervin’s and Gervin was a better rebounder, and Gervin maintained a higher level of play than Dumars did late in his career and put up a higher scoring average. Dumars was not an instant all-star like the others on this list, and he wasn’t as athletic, nor did he have the longevity, but what he did have was a humble mindset, and a strong work ethic. Dumars played the team game, and played it well, working hard to keep his shot crisp in the gym, and working even harder to keep up on defence. Yeah, his rebounding wasn’t impressive, but like Stockton who was the best pure point guard, Dumars was also a pure shooting guard. He played on a strong rebounding team (Laimbeer, Rodman, Salley, MaHorn, Edwards and Aguire), and so focused on his job, defending, and shooting. His defensive prowess was the stuff of legend, and had to be as he helped the Piston win two titles, make three NBA finals appearances and five straight conference finals appearances, and impressive feat considering the Pistons were playing at a time when the Lakers and Celtics dynasties of the 80’s were still in full swing, and the Bulls were entering their zentih, playing the Pistons in three straight years. Where do you think Jordan learned to dominant defences? He learned how to do that by having to work through Dumars stifling defence every year in the playoffs. Dumars was also a stellar offensive player as well, shooting over 48% from the field in his rookie year and between 45-50% for most of his career. He was also an excellent passer, handed out around 5 assists a game most of his career, and only causing between 1.9-2.6 turnovers a game for most of his career, putting his assist-to-turnover average above Bryant and Gervin. Team ball is most important to me, and Dumars understood it was a team game more than Bryant or Gervin. He’s also one of those classy guys with a strong sense of loyalty, and he stayed with the Pistons even through a rough rebuilding process when he could have left to chase titles with New York or L.A., and served as a mentor to players. You gotta love a guy who only wears one jersey throughout his career.
5. Kobe Bryant
I would normally hesitate on putting somebody who is still in their prime, but Kobe has accomplished enough in his career that his spot in the top ten is set in stone (until at least the next generation of all-star shooting guards). It could be argued that Bryant is on a par with Jordan in terms of his defensive prowess, and when Shaq was shipped out of La La Land, Kobe threw up a career high 35+ a game, on a par with Jordan’s second highest single-season scoring average, and the highest scoring average the league had seen (outside of Jordan), since the Baylor/Chamberlain era. Kobe is also a strong rebounder and passer, getting 5+ each a game for most of his career, though his turnovers are a little too high for comfort, and even his best field-goal percentages don’t match up with Jordan, Gervin, Lewis and Drexler. His maturity level has always been in question as well. His rookie season saw a great athletic talent whose horrible shot selection and disgustingly low field-goal percentage had Laker fans questioning the Vlade Divac trade. His sophomore season wasn’t much better, and his best percentage hasn’t even touched 48%, let alone 50%. His immaturity hurt his shooting percentage, but that’s not all. His inability to play in the context of a team setting got Shaq shipped out and encouraged Malone to opt not to return. A dynasty that recruited new all-stars every year fell apart and played like a lottery team in the NBA finals. Since then Kobe has had a hard time melding with teammates, and threatened to send the Lakers into re-building mode one off-season, showing impatience toward the development of a straight-out-of-high school rookie Andrew Bynum (thankfully Shaq, Eddie Jones and Nick Van Exel were all more patient with Bryant when he was drafted out of high school), and that re-building mode would still be going on right now if it wasn’t for Memphis’s cost cutting trade that gave the Lakers Pao Gasol for Kwambe Brown. The success of the team now is not because of Kobe’s talent, but because they got lucky enough to turn things around with the Gasol trade. Kobe has been well behaved since, but we all know his ego can easily cause another devastating eruption at any moment. If you put Jordan alongside Odom, or Gasol, I think we all know the NBA finals would have went differently ‘08. Kobe has lost two NBA finals so far, something Jordan never did, and Jordan had a maturity level that left room for loose canons like Rodman, and pure scorers like Kukoc, while also allowing leaders like Pippen take care of the ball and set up plays, while hitting clutch shots and playing stellar defence. Kobe can score and defend, but his ego won’t allow him to work with some talented players and he has failed to make players better. Had Kobe played on the second three-peat Bulls team instead of Jordan, that team would have fallen apart. That maturity, while it doesn’t make him any less talented, does make him less effective, and if one need proof that he is not the facilitator that Bird, Nash, Duncan and Magic were, one need only look at how much better Carlon Bulter played alongside Arenas, another 30 point scorer who helped Butler flourish, rather than flounder. The Lakers are great now, and Kobe is a phenomenal talent, but he can’t make a team meld together the way Jordan could, and the way Duncan and Nash can. And Jordan never needed a new crew of all-star every year to win a title the way Kobe did with the Lakers. And that shit about Kobe being able to close out games is an overstatement to say the least, and all you need to do is watch the ‘08 NBA finals when Gasol and Odom helped build up a 20+ point lead in the first half, and watch Kobe get schooled by Allen and Pierce while Boston came back and put the Lakers away, the turning point of the series.
4. Clyde Drexler
In my book, Drexler is easily the most underrated player on this list. Drexler had to play in the shadow of Michael Jordan, and he also played on a deep team that didn’t demand he put up the scoring numbers Jordan had to put up for the Bulls. And because the team was deep he didn’t need to put up 38+ minutes a game like Jordan needed to do. In turn his scoring numbers were a little lower than Jordan, and since he played on a team with several strong rebounders (Buck Williams, Jerome Kersey, Sam Bowie, Cliff Robinson and Kevin Duckworth), Drexler wasn’t required to work the boards like Jordan, though he did better than average. Drexler also had two quality starting shooting guards in Drazen Petrovic and Danny Ainge (and even Walter Davis) backing him up, and with strong shooters like those sitting on the bench, any coach would want to make sure he got some minutes for them, especially since the Blazers had Terry Porter to handle the rock at the point, and had post players who called for a double team. All these factors really served to dilute Drexler’s stats, much like Havliecek’s stats were diluted by playing with a great Boston squad. The real damper on Drexler’s stats was the fact that he played for a small market team like Portland. Had Drexler played for New York, or L.A., the officials would have had been putting him on the line every time he drove the ball, but playing for a small market team that the NBA didn’t want to see do well, the Blazers didn’t get the benefit the Jordan, and Ewing, and Magic and Bird got (it was a miracle that the Pistons won two titles in that era). In terms of titles, Drexler also paled next to Jordan (just one to Jordan’s six), but Drexler had to face the Lakers, Rockets and Jazz in the playoffs over and over, not to mention the Suns and Robinson’s Spurs, and when they made it to the finals, they had Detroit and Chicago to deal with. Of course Drexler eventually won himself a title, and with the Rockets, in a post season that saw the Rockets topple the teams with the four best records in the NBA, two of them (the Jazz and the Spurs) having 60+ wins, so Drexler was capable of competing at the highest level, he just happen to play in the league at a time when it was extremely competitive. And keep in mind, no other team in the history of the league had ever defeated the teams with the four best records in the league. Drexler’s stats, diluted though they were, were still very impressive. He averaged 6 or 7 rebounds a game for most of his career from the guard position, even at the age of 35, and his assists were always over 5 a game, and as high a 8 a game in his best season. His field-goal percentages were also great, much of his career being at around 50%, and a little over 47% on his career. And in seasons where he was called upon to score, he put up nearly 30 points a game. Defensively, Drexler was only out done by Jordan and Dumars in his own generation, and the only knock on his game was his range: he just wasn’t a great three point shooter, but he at least knew his limitations and only took them when he was open.
3. John Havlicek
Selecting number one on this list may have been easier than the others, but selecting the order for the rest of list is not so easy. Havlicek though was is deserving a spot near the top of the list, and not just because he he’s got 8 rings. First, it is important to note that Havlicek didn’t just ride the Russell train for all of his rings, because the last two he earned without Russell, and the few holdovers from the Russell days that were left, were in the twilight of their careers when Havlicek won the finals MVP in 74. His career averages may not compare to Jordan and West, but neither of those two joined a dynasty in their rookie year and had to earn every shot as a rookie from the future HOFers that comprised the Celtics squad of the 60’s. And unlike many players, who are on the decline past 30, Havlicek put up his best numbers in his 30’s (in part because so many of the HOFers were gone or playing limited minutes). And when he had to earn his opportunities on offence, he worked plenty hard in other areas, and he crashed the boards at a time when team rebounding wasn’t popular and most shooting guards were running down the court waiting for some easy fast break points. Havlicek averaged over 6 boards a game for most of his career, and grabbed as many as 9 boards a game in his best season (higher than Jordan ever averaged) and over 7 boards for five years out of his career, some for them in his 30’s. Like West, his scoring averages were lower due to the fact that there were no three points while Havlicek was playing, but like some other great shooting guards, his scoring averages don’t reflect how good he was at scoring since he was on such a deep team and shared the scoring responsibilities. Other guards like Michael Finely, and Clyde Drexler, have also played on deep teams and though they each could have put up scoring numbers more comparable with Jordan, Gervin and Bryant, they played for deep teams and shared the ball. Looking at his rebounding numbers, his assists (7.5 in his best two season and almost 5 for his career average), it is clear that he was a great all around player, and his hard work on the boards challenged how other guards played their game and set a standard for every guard that would follow. It could be argued that Havlicek is the reason centers don’t grab 20+ boards a game anymore since everybody on the floor is expected to chase after rebounds and before Havlicek, most guards just ran down the court to jump start the offence, leaving centers and power forwards to collect the boards. Havlicek helped redefine the shooting guard duties, and illustrated that the meagre 20 points per game he put up his first ten seasons didn’t illustrate his scoring potential, only his ability to play in a team setting rather than an individual.
2. Jerry West
This guy is the NBA logo, so he’s gotta be good right? Of course, it is pathetic this spot, of all sport, uses a white guy for their logo, and then colours his profile in white to make him even whiter. Like WTF?!?!?!? That said, West is always in the conversation when you speak about the best clutch shooters, and while his scoring averages aren’t as high as Jordan’s or Bryant’s or Gervin’s, West is in a tight race with those guys when it comes to single season scoring averages, which is impressive considering the fact that for much of West’s career, the three-point line was not in effect. When it comes to working the boards and passing the rock, West had also developed a strong all around game early in his career, and at 24, an age where Jordan was scoring lots, but getting less than 6 boards and 5 assists, West was already over 30 points a game, and grabbing nearly 8 boards and handing out 5.5 assists, a pretty good all-around game for such a young player. His average didn’t stay so high throughout his career as West played on a deep team and shared the ball with Chamberlain, Baylor (two of the best scorers in league history) and Gail Goodrich, but his clutch shooting remained throughout his career. He was also a solid defender, and though the NBA did not keep track of steals for most of his career, they did in his last season, and even at the age of 36, West was snagging in 2.6 steals a game, one of the highest steals-per-game averages for a player of his age (Jordan couldn’t even get that high past the age of thirty). Jordan also had great longevity in his career, but West did as well, and that is something that is rare at this position since the guards rely on quickness and athleticism, which is the first thing that goes with age (which is why front court players can hang on until 40, and most point guards go down hill after 30). I do believe Jordan is the clear cut number one on this list, but I don’t think the gap between him and West is as great as most assume.
1. Michael Jordan
It could be argued that Michael Jordan is the most overrated player in the history of the game, since so many claim he is the greatest ever, but the fact of the matter is, even if Russell is a better defender, and Sockton is a better passer, and even if Larry Bird is a better shooters, and even if Oscar Robertson is a better all around player, and even if Wilt Chamberlain is a better scorer, and even if Robert Horry has more rings, and even if he needed the officials to give him more call than I can count to win 4 of his 6 NBA titles, Jordan is still the greatest shooting guard the league has ever seen. I wouldn’t say greatest ever, because Russell, Wilt, Robertson, and Kareem would all be higher on my list, and anybody who argued to put Karl Malone, Stockton, Olajuwon, Bird or Magic above Jordan would have a case, but none of those players are shooting guards. So why is he the greatest shooting guard of all time? Well, he isn’t the best shooter (Ray Allen is a better shooter), and I wouldn’t even say he’s the best clutch shooter (I would put West and Miller above Jordan in that respect), but he is a great shooter, and he is the third greatest clutch shooter (even if he has to push off on the defender to get the shot off, he still hit’s the shot). What he does do better than anybody is defend in the clutch, and there can’t be enough said about Jordan’s defence. Jordan could defend any other shooting guard on the perimeter, or in the post, or on the drive, and do so effectively (even if Nick Anderson schooled him once in the playoffs, and even if the young Allen Iverson pulled a shake-and-bake on Jordan and made him look like Yao Ming trying to guard Marbury). When it comes to scoring, there is no shooting guard in league history who put up higher single season average than Jordan’s 37.1, and his career average is 30.1, the highest, not only for his position, but for all positions (though we all know Wilt’s wouldn’t just be tied with Jordan, but about 10 point higher had he not had the humility to defer scoring responsibilities to Baylor and West while he got 20 boards a game. So he’s the best scorer and the best defender at his position. The season Jordan got 37.1 a game though, he was a big fish in a small pond and the Bulls didn’t even finished at .500 and failed to make the playoffs (though that would give them home court in the first round of the east these days). His assist and rebounding averages were decent that year at 4.6 and 5.2 respectively, but two years later he redefined his game and settled for 32.5 points and 8 assists and 8 rebounds, not only making himself a better player, but helping his team on the boards, and creating plays for teammates, and earning the Bulls a division crown (even if the Pistons spanked them in the playoffs- which the Pistons did three years in a row). Later in his career, Jordan continued to improve his game, he added a dagger sharp fade-away jumper in his 30’s when his athleticism slowed a little (and by a little, I mean very little), and even allowed Pippen to share ball handling responsibilities. 32/8/8 was the closest thing to Oscar Robertson the league had seen since Robertson retired (though Bird and Magic were both close to the tipple double). The best defender, the best scorer, and the best all around shooting guard the league has ever seen, Jordan makes selecting the number one spot on the shooting guard list easy.