Top Ten Small Forwards
In gauging the top ten small forwards, this list takes into consideration the impact and value to the team, personal performance and stats, and talent. Some talented players are on deeper teams and have smaller roles (Ron Artest, Lamar Odom, Richard Jefferson and Shawn Marion) and in turn have meek stats, while others who are equally talented, or perhaps a little less so, have bigger roles on weaker teams (Al Harrington, Danny Granger), so it is hard to compare similar players who play different roles for different teams. So the teams success, personal stats and talent are all taken into consideration.
Honourable Mention
Tayshawn Prince/Shane Battier
Two of the best defenders in the league; ’nuff said.
Stephen Jackson
Jackson’s talent is clear, as are his potentially beneficial leadership skills, but he is unhappy (understandably) with Goldenstate’s direction and has put himself in the dog house by demanding a trade. I don’t expect him to make a very big impact this season considering Goldenstate’s inability to trade him (what with his sizable contract and all), coupled with his unwillingness to work with this team, but things could turnaround.
Caron Butler
Its not that I don’t think he is as good as some of the guys on this list, he is, he will just be sharing minutes with Mike Miller so his role will be diminished, though his talent will not be. Washington is deeper on the perimeter and has their top scorer back, so Butler, being the team player he is, will see his numbers dip in order to help the team.
Lamar Odom
He plays both forward spots, and he plays his best when he and Pau Gasol are sharing power forward and center duties at the same time, but his diverse skill set and height gives him many advantages at small forward, and even if his numbers seem meek, his impact is huge. With Ron Artest on the team, his minutes may be further reduced, but his talent will still help the Lakers win games.
Ron Artest
The best defender at his position? Maybe, but I think he is a little overrated in this respect, though still very much among the league’s elite. Like Butler and Odom he will be taking a reduced role to help his team win and so may not put up the numbers that his peers do, but if this list was purely on talent and not also about over-all impact (the MVP factor) and numbers, Artest and Odom would both be in the top ten for sure.
Richard Jefferson
Jefferson is a talented all-around player and knows how to win (he’s been to the finals twice with the Nets), and with his new team, The Spurs, I expect he will bring a lot to the team, and even if his number are meeker than in seasons past, he will help to create some match-up issues for opposing teams.
Jason Richardson
Richardson is a talented scorer and though he doesn’t have the complete game that some on this list have, he has mastered the parts of the games he’s good at, and even when he’s on the losing team, his high energy level and ability to break away to the basket provide entertainment to all in attendance.
Josh Howard/Shawn Marion
I’m not sure how these two talented small forwards are going to work out the minutes, but Drew Gooden will be eating up all the reserve minutes at power forward so it looks like one of these guys is going to have to learn to play shooting guard if either of them want more than 24 minutes a game. Both these guys are great players, Howard’s a great scorer and solid all-around player, and Marion an elite defender, rebounder and all around player. Outside of Boston and Cleveland, the Mavs may have the best small forward rotation in the league (though that doesn’t make up for their lack of a center).
John Salmons, Al Thorton and Thad Young also get a nod from me as solid contributors for their respective teams.
10. Al Harrington
Harrington has long been an NBA prospect it seems. Indiana chased after him twice, Atlanta signed him as a young free agent, and the Warriors pick him up expecting him to be an improvement on Mike Dunleavy Jr. (which I think he is). But Harrington has had trouble getting his minutes. In Indiana the Pacers were still trying to get their footing in the post-melee era, and in Goldenstate he saw more time on the bench than he had expected when Don Nelson (I know, I’m shaking my head too) went with a small line (that could have easily included Harrington) and benched the talented young forward. New York though has Harrington a new lease on life and when he first arrived in New York he indeed managed to put up numbers the surpassed most on this list, though he couldn’t keep those averages up all season. Harrington is a natural scorer, who works the glass and keeps up on defence. The only knock on Harrington is that he’s never had a particularly high field-goal percentage (though he has maintained a respectable one), and he has never been much of a play maker. He doesn’t create a lot of turnovers, but nor does he create a lot of assists, and the former outnumber the later, which is never good. I expect Harrington to have another solid year with the Knicks and once they sort out their roster after free agency in the 2010 offseason I expect that Harrington will end up being a key role player and secondary scoring option, but as of right now, he is the most consistent player the Knicks have and outside of David Lee.
9. Rudy Gay
I’m having a hard time placing Gay for a number of reasons, most of all the Iverson/Randolph factor. The past couple of seasons Gay has been the best scorer on a team that didn’t have a lot of scorers, and though he remains their best option at small forward and will certainly be starting there, it is unclear where he will fit on the offensive pecking order. Randolph will certainly call for the ball in the post and Iverson, even if he is coming off the bench, will want the ball in his hands, and Mike Conley and O.J. Mayo have both displayed the ability to handle the ball and score. Talent alone should dictate that Gay will still be the first option of offence, but Mayo and Randolph are deserving of as many touches, and Iverson and Conley will likely be handling the ball a lot while rookie Hasheem Thabeet, and least year’s rookie sensation Marc Gasol will also be earning their own shots. This is a deep squad and Gay’s position is unclear, but he remains a great athlete, he has a long lean body that creates match-up problems and he works the glass and on defence, so its hard to imagine him not being the go-to guy on this squad. Either way he is one of the top young small forwards and deserving of a spot in the top ten.
8. Josh Smith
Josh Smith is one of those unique players, athletic, muscular, hard working and great all around player, and by all around I mean he knows how to drop numbers into each statistical category. Like Gerald Wallce, he works the glass, gets some steals, gets some blocks, scores some points and hands out more assists than he does turnovers, and his field-goal percentage has gone up ever year since his sophomore effort (up to almost 50% last season). The only whole in his game seems to be long range shooting (which is an excusable default at his position) and at the free-throw line where he has actually gotten worse over the years (58% last year, after shooting over 70% the year before- I’m scratching my head too). The only knock on Smith is that he’s not a power forward, which is the position he plays much of the time. His height and work ethic allow him to keep up with most power forwards, but when you watch his game it is clear that he is a small forward by nature. He’s a great defender on the perimeter, and he is athletic and quick, but the Hawks, who have been short a true power forward the last couple of seasons, have been forced to play Smith at power forward a lot. With the addition of Joe Smith, and the emergence of two solid rebounding centers in Zaza and Al Horford, I imagine Josh Smith will get to play more minutes at his natural position, and I expect the Hawks to make a run at the division title with their newly acquired depth.
7. Hedo Turkoglu
Easily one of the most underrated players in the league, while the Cavs ran into the offseason looking for somebody to match up with Dwight Howard for the 2010 post season, the Raptors went and did the Cavs a huge favour, they picked up one of the most important pieces of Orlando’s success last season. While Howard is a dominant player, the Cavs front court made him work for every bucket and every board, but Turkoglu took advantage of his unique skill set and height advantage to give the Magic the upper hand over the Cavs. Turkoglu is not as great a shooter as many imagine him to be (only 41% last year), but he is a great three point shooter and he is a solid rebounder from his position (5+ a game), but the most important aspect of Turkoglu’s game is his ability to pass. He, like Paul Pierce and LBJ (and Scottie Pippen in years gone by), can play the point forward position. He can bring the ball up the court and set up plays, create for himself off the dribble and allow an undersized shooting guard (guys like Ben Gordon, Eddie House and Monta Ellis to name a few) to come in and spell the point guard without causing his team to give up anything in terms of playmaking, and when Jameer Nelson went down with injury, Turkoglu’s ball handling skills are what carried the Magic through the regular season. He is not a dominant offensive or defensive player, but he is solid at both and his unique skill set creates options for his coach, while his height advantage creates interesting miss-matches that also allows his coaches to exploit opposing team’s short comings. He may not put up the numbers that some others do, but he has as big an impact as many of the most talented small forwards in the league.
6. Gerald Wallace
Wallace is the best rebounders on this list, as well as one of the best athletes and best all-around players. He’s even got an edge on LBJ in a couple statistical categories (rebounding and steals). He works the glass, he busts his ass off on defence, he shoots around 48% from the floor and 80% from the charity stripe, he hands out more assists than he does turnovers and gets almost as many steals as he does turnovers and the only real knock is that he isn’t an elite scorer and could afford to lower his personal fouls (though he is not in the red in this respect by any means). Even when new coach Larry Brown seemed uninterested in Wallace and put him on the trading block, he still busted his ass off and eventually gained (or at least seemed to) the respect of Larry Brown (which isn’t easy to do if you ask any of his former players). He gets steals, some blocks, he passes, rebounds and scorers, and has a team first mentality. If he were on a team like the Spurs he’d be even more dangerous, but as it is he is playing for the Bobcats, and while fans may not get to watch him in the post season, they can still certainly watch this very talented player in the regular season.
5. Carmelo Anthony
I’m sure there are going to be some pissed of Denver fans who think Carmelo should be a little higher on the list (if anybody from Denver ever happens to my blog), but Danny Granger, though a later bloomer when compared next to Carmelo, is still a better player right now. Carmelo has been very fortunate to have been surrounded by a lot of talent for most of his career, but it is clear that despite having a solid front court around him (Nene, Camby, Martin and Andersen have all be working the boards for Denver in the past), and though he has always had a couple other scoring options, he has never been able to lead Denver into serious title contention. That did not happen until Billups came to town, so Anthony just doesn’t have that intangible leadership quality that separates the elite players in the league (and Anthony is an elite player). That said, Anthony is a great scorer, a great athlete, a solid defender and a great rebounder, and for all those reasons he simply cannot be left off of this list.
4. Danny Granger
Granger’s rebounds actually dipped a little bit last season, but he was called upon to play small-forward almost exclusively, so that is understandable. That said, his assists did go up and personal fouls came down slightly while his scoring soared along with his leadership skills. Last season Granger saw the Pacer’s organization lean on him and he responded in turn. His defensive stats were solid (over a block and a steal a game), his scoring jumped up to 25+ a game (second only to LBJ at his position), and the Pacers actually saw an improvement in their team. That is not to say Granger has perfected his game, he’s got to bring down his personal fouls, as well as his turnover to be the perfect compliment to his team, and he may have to relinquish some of the scoring duties and defer (like Paul Pierce has done) if the Pacers are to gain any ground on other Eastern conference teams, but Granger has provided the kind of responsible leadership that the Pacers have been in constant search of in the post-melee era and Granger is the type of guy that will lead by example to help improve his team. I expect the Pacers to make the playoffs this year and even make some noise (a first-round series win is not out of reach for this team), and I expect Granger to be at the center of this team’s success.
3. Kevin Durant
In the 07/08 season, despite easily winning the Rookie of the Year honours, Durant showed many of the classic problems that plague rookies. High turnovers (3 a game), low field-goal percentage (43%) and low three-point percentage (28%), though he did manage to keep his personal fouls below 2 a game. In his sophomore season there was dramatic improvement. His rebounding and assist numbers jumped up, and his field-goal percentage (up to 47%) and his three-point percentage (42%) both saw increases and his team got better. Durant is playing for a weaker team in a competitive western conference, and though his team got off to a rough start last year, they played competitive ball the second half of the season and did not provide simple and easy fodder for the league’s elite. I don’t imagine this year that they will be able to break into the elite, or even the playoffs for that matter, but they have a talented young team and Durant is that team’s leader. The only thing he really needs to improve is his turnover rate, and he could afford to be more of a defensive presence (not that he‘s bad in this regard, just not outstanding yet).
2. Paul Pierce
There are a number of small forwards who put up more points, or more steals, or more boards than Pierce, but Pierce remains an elite defender, even if his defensive stats don’t rank amongst the league leaders (just look at how he handled LBJ and Kobe Bryant in the ‘08 playoffs). Pierce is a solid play maker and gives his team a ball-handling option when the point guard is on the bench, and he is also a team-first player who took a back seat as a scoring option (despite the fact he’s easily a 25+ point scorer), to help the team perform better. There are some younger guys (like Granger) who are coming up and will give Pierce a run for his money, but his experience, ball handling skills and defence (and his ring) place him just a shade under James and a level above the rest of the players at his position.
1. LeBron James
While some may argue that James is not the clear cut best all-around player in the league, there is no doubt; James is certainly the best small-forward and an easy choice for number one on this list. LeBron James is the top scorer among small forward, the top assist maker, and the best rebounder at small forward outside of Gerald Wallace (who played some minutes at power forward for the Bobcats who were short a decent power forward). And Wallace is the only small forward to get more steals that James. As for blocks, AK-47 and Danny Granger were the only small forwards to log more blocks per game than James. Not to mention he is the reigning MVP, he’s great on defence, always takes the best scorer on the perimeter, and he is arguably the best offensive player at his position, and not only can he always get his shot, but he is clutch as well. He proved that last year by making some big shots in the Orlando series, and the season when the Cavs made it to the NBA finals for the first time, James reeled of 20+ straight point at the end of the fourth quarter and into an overtime against the Pistons. There is no reason that I can think of to have James anywhere other than number one on this list.